A new poll ranks the sexiest songs of all time. 1. Olivia Newton-John - Physical 2. Rod Stewart - Tonight's the Night 3. Boyz II Men - I'll Make Love To You Jesus Christ. How old were the people who voted for these songs? I think we can do a bit better. Focus: Top three sexiest songs ever. Alt Focus: Any funny story about music playing while you were getting laid. I can't think what that would entail, but just to try and keep it from being a bunch of random YouTube clips.